Winner of the 2012 Tony Award for Best Actor in a Musical (Once)

Winner of the 2012 Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album (Once)

Nominated for a 2012 Outer Critics Cirlce Award (Once)

Honoree of the 2012 Drama League Award for Distinguished Performance (Once)

Nominated for a 2006 Helen Hayes award for Best Actor in a Play (The Subject Was Roses)